Ever wish you could read your customer's mind? Gerald
Zaltman, a marketing professor at the Harvard Business School,
uses brain scans, psychotherapy-like interviews, and his patented
Zaltman Metaphor Elicitation Technique (ZMET) to help the likes of
Procter & Gamble, Pfizer, General Motors, and Coca-Cola get
inside the consumer's head. Author of the forthcoming How Customers
Think (Harvard Business School Press, January 2003), Zaltman spoke
to us about metaphor, Vanilla Coke, and triggering disgust.
Q: What's wrong with focus groups?
A: At least
95% of the thinking that drives our behavior occurs
unconsciously--much of what we think of as conscious will is an
after-the-fact construction. So people are often buying products for
reasons they're not fully aware of.
Q: So buying motor oil might actually be my way of saying,
"I love you." How do you figure that out?
A: You need to
engage other languages of the mind. Every metaphor reveals lots of
hidden knowledge. So for a recent study we asked people to bring
eight-by-ten pictures that represented their thoughts and feelings
about snack foods. For example, one person showed up with a picture
of someone covered with bees. Then a trained interviewer asks them
to use the pictures to tell a story, while a specialist in digital
imaging helps them form the images into a collage. You're able to
get a very robust set of insights.
Q: What was the bee picture all about?
A: That
person had a lot of confidence that she wouldn't get stung--that she
could safely indulge in snack foods without running the risks of
harm that everyone else talks about. So there was a bit of defiance
to it.
Q: So what do the brain scans do?
A: We call it
"interviewing the brain." By monitoring the blood flows in the brain
and seeing cortices light up, you're able to draw certain
inferences: whether a [new-product] stimulus is being experienced in
a negative or positive way; whether people are able to visualize it;
whether areas of the brain involved in memory retrieval are active.
We're close to having some new technology. It's kind of like a cap
you put on people.
Q: Did Coke try any of your techniques before it launched
Vanilla Coke?
A: No.
Q: Because I have a very vivid association with that
product.
A: What is your association?
Q: Puke.
A: Actually, you're addressing an
interesting area. We study joy and happiness but never disgust--and
yet it's the foundation for so many industries: cosmetics, personal
appearance, the whole industry of being clean. If you want to know
what attracts consumers, you have to know what repels them. Because
you don't want to inadvertently trigger it.